NYS RENEWABLE
INTELLIGENCE
  • Dashboard
  • Night Desk
  • Projects
  • Opposition Monitor
  • Actors
  • Funding Network
  • Disinformation
  • Legislation
  • Knowledgebase
  • Counter-Measures
  • Reports
  • Map
  • Data Explorer
  • Admin

Quick Search

Oswegatchie Solar Farm

Oswegatchie, St. Lawrence County · Northline Energy · Docket 23-F-0091

8
All projects
SolarPublic CommentUnder ReviewORES 25MW+

120 MW across 780 acres of low-yield cropland north of Heuvelton. Opposition is concentrated on farmland conversion and is being coordinated with a parallel campaign in Lisbon.

Developer

Northline Energy

Location

Oswegatchie, St. Lawrence County

Capacity

120 MW

Docket

23-F-0091

Next milestone

Jun 24, 2025

47Elevated

Risk score

Opposition intensity 58/100 across 4 tracked actors and 6 filed documents.

Open response plan →

Permitting Timeline(6 milestones)Every recorded procedural event on this docket, with the actor responsible and whether the outcome helped or hurt the project.Every recorded procedural event on this docket, with the actor responsible and whether the outcome helped or hurt the project.

2 adverse events
  1. Mar 19, 202494-c application filedProcedural

    Northline Energy

    780 acres, 71% classified as soil groups 5–7 by the NYS Agricultural Land Classification.

  2. Jun 5, 2024Town passes a resolution of oppositionAdverse

    Oswegatchie Town Board

    Non-binding resolution 5–0; explicitly cites loss of agricultural character.

  3. Sep 17, 2024Agricultural mitigation plan submittedFavourable

    Northline Energy

    Sheep grazing on 430 acres under contract with two North Country graziers; soil health monitoring every 3 years.

  4. Dec 3, 2024Coordinated comment campaign detectedAdverse

    Farmland Forever NY

    312 comments filed in nine days, 240 sharing a near-identical opening paragraph.

  5. Mar 27, 2025Ag & Markets issues a favourable reviewFavourable

    NYS Dept. of Agriculture & Markets

    Found the mitigation plan consistent with agrivoltaic guidelines; recommended two added conditions.

  6. Jun 24, 2025Completeness determination expectedUpcoming

    NYS ORES

    Starts the one-year statutory clock for a final siting decision.

Full docket historyFiled Mar 19, 2024 · no decision yet

Opposition at this Project(28 appearances)Organizations and individuals recorded in hearing minutes, filings, and monitored channels for this docket.Organizations and individuals recorded in hearing minutes, filings, and monitored channels for this docket.

  • FFFarmland Forever NY10 appearancesAstroturf OperatorEnvironmental ImpactOther / UnknownComment-generation tooling; 240 of 312 comments matched a single template.
  • NCNorth Country Preservation Alliance6 appearancesLitigatorEnvironmental ImpactVisual / AestheticSame coalition active in the Black River docket.
  • EMElaine Marchetti5 appearancesLitigatorEnvironmental ImpactFiled the procedural objection to the completeness schedule.
  • GHGordon Hitchings7 appearancesIdeologueOther / UnknownProperty Value ClaimsFormer county legislator; frames 94-c as an Albany land grab.
All actorsFunding network

Arguments Deployed(100 statements)Every recorded public statement on this docket, classified into the platform's argument taxonomy.Every recorded public statement on this docket, classified into the platform's argument taxonomy.

100Statements

Dominant framing

Environmental Impact accounts for 47% of statements on this docket — hover a category for the counter-framing note.

Trace these narratives

Documents & Filings(6)Source documents ingested for this project: ORES and local board filings, adopted local laws, hearing minutes, studies, and press coverage.Source documents ingested for this project: ORES and local board filings, adopted local laws, hearing minutes, studies, and press coverage.

Open in knowledgebase

Recommended Counter-Measures(3)Interventions ranked by expected impact on this specific decision point, drawn from the counter-measures playbook.Interventions ranked by expected impact on this specific decision point, drawn from the counter-measures playbook.

Pillar 3
  • 1File the duplicate-comment analysis into the docketShow ORES that 77% of the opposition comment volume derives from one template with one originating IP range.Low effortHigh impactBefore June 24
  • 2Put the graziers in front of the county Farm BureauTwo contracted sheep operators can speak to income per acre better than any consultant.Low effortHigh impactQ2 2025
  • 3Publish the soil classification map71% of the site is soil group 5–7; the “prime farmland” framing does not survive the county soil survey.Low effortMedium impactImmediate
Open full playbook