NYS RENEWABLE
INTELLIGENCE
  • Dashboard
  • Night Desk
  • Projects
  • Opposition Monitor
  • Actors
  • Funding Network
  • Disinformation
  • Legislation
  • Knowledgebase
  • Counter-Measures
  • Reports
  • Map
  • Data Explorer
  • Admin

Quick Search

Black River Solar Center

Le Ray, Jefferson County · Northline Energy · Docket 22-F-0388

8
All projects
Solar + StorageDecisionApproved w/ ConditionsORES 25MW+

180 MW of solar plus a 40 MW / 160 MWh battery across 1,140 acres in Le Ray and Pamelia. Permitted by ORES under 94-c with conditions on avian monitoring, glare, and a Fort Drum coordination protocol.

Developer

Northline Energy

Location

Le Ray, Jefferson County

Capacity

180 MW + 160 MWh

Docket

22-F-0388

Next milestone

Jul 15, 2025

34Low

Risk score

Opposition intensity 67/100 across 4 tracked actors and 7 filed documents.

Open response plan →

Permitting Timeline(7 milestones)Every recorded procedural event on this docket, with the actor responsible and whether the outcome helped or hurt the project.Every recorded procedural event on this docket, with the actor responsible and whether the outcome helped or hurt the project.

1 adverse event
  1. Jan 24, 202394-c application submitted to ORESProcedural

    Northline Energy

    Docket 22-F-0388; 1,140 acres under option across 14 landowners.

  2. May 16, 2023Municipality files a substantive local law waiver challengeAdverse

    Town of Le Ray

    Argued the town's 2022 setback law was not unreasonably burdensome; ORES rejected the claim in October.

  3. Sep 12, 2023Intervenor funding awardedProcedural

    NYS ORES

    $118K distributed, $71K of it to a coalition that retained counsel from an out-of-state firm.

  4. Feb 8, 2024Adjudicatory hearing on glare and avian impactProcedural

    ORES Administrative Law Judge

    Fort Drum airspace glare modelling accepted; grassland bird mitigation acreage disputed.

  5. Sep 27, 2024Permit issued with 23 conditionsFavourable

    NYS ORES

    Includes 210 acres of grassland bird offset, a glare protocol with Fort Drum, and quarterly monitoring.

  6. Nov 14, 2024Article 78 petition filed and dismissedFavourable

    North Country Preservation Alliance

    Albany County Supreme Court dismissed for lack of standing; no appeal filed within the window.

  7. Jul 15, 2025Pre-construction compliance filing dueUpcoming

    Northline Energy

    Final grading, decommissioning surety, and the avian monitoring plan for year one.

Full docket historyFiled Jan 24, 2023 · decided Sep 27, 2024

Opposition at this Project(39 appearances)Organizations and individuals recorded in hearing minutes, filings, and monitored channels for this docket.Organizations and individuals recorded in hearing minutes, filings, and monitored channels for this docket.

  • NCNorth Country Preservation Alliance14 appearancesLitigatorEnvironmental ImpactVisual / AestheticReceived $71K of intervenor funding; filed the Article 78 petition.
  • NFNYers for Local Control8 appearancesTrade AssociationOther / UnknownRan the home-rule campaign supporting Le Ray's waiver challenge.
  • EMElaine Marchetti11 appearancesLitigatorEnvironmental ImpactProperty Value ClaimsCounsel of record for the alliance; also appears in the Oswegatchie docket.
  • TKThomas Kowalczyk6 appearancesMedia AmplifierVisual / AestheticOther / UnknownWeekly column in a regional outlet; 31 anti-siting pieces since 2023.
All actorsFunding network

Arguments Deployed(105 statements)Every recorded public statement on this docket, classified into the platform's argument taxonomy.Every recorded public statement on this docket, classified into the platform's argument taxonomy.

105Statements

Dominant framing

Environmental Impact accounts for 39% of statements on this docket — hover a category for the counter-framing note.

Trace these narratives

Documents & Filings(7)Source documents ingested for this project: ORES and local board filings, adopted local laws, hearing minutes, studies, and press coverage.Source documents ingested for this project: ORES and local board filings, adopted local laws, hearing minutes, studies, and press coverage.

Open in knowledgebase

Recommended Counter-Measures(3)Interventions ranked by expected impact on this specific decision point, drawn from the counter-measures playbook.Interventions ranked by expected impact on this specific decision point, drawn from the counter-measures playbook.

Pillar 3
  • 1Publicise the grassland bird offset as a conservation win210 permanently protected acres is a stronger local story than the permit itself; place it with Audubon NY.Low effortMedium impactOngoing
  • 2Document the intervenor funding outcomeTrack how $71K of ratepayer intervenor money was spent on out-of-state counsel for a dismissed petition.Medium effortHigh impactBefore the next docket
  • 3Brief neighbouring town boards during constructionPamelia and Wilna will see traffic; a monthly construction bulletin pre-empts the next moratorium push.Medium effortMedium impactQ3 2025
Open full playbook